That Fateful Night

On top of the fact that I moved on YOU night 2

The Hunter wrote:But aristocrat — if I moved EVERY night how am I on the witch team??

If you moved every night you are not on the witch team.

You’ve been seen moving one night, if memory serves. Which it often does not.

And I get it. I’m not a fan of lynching fast either (I am a fan of calling out names fast)

But if we don’t then we’re all going to die regardless if we keep saying no lynch

The Aristocrat wrote:

The Hunter wrote:But aristocrat — if I moved EVERY night how am I on the witch team??

If you moved every night you are not on the witch team.

You’ve been seen moving one night, if memory serves.  Which it often does not.

I don’t know why this is a me issue when anyone else could have opted to move on me for literally ANY of the other nights

And over half those moves were on yourself… which like I guess is fine but is an ethics issue for me, personally.

This doesn’t apply to me, but you really made it sound like you would kill people who ran into you with your protection. You moved on yourself often as well, so my guess is people didn’t want to waste their move. (Protectors affect all roles, right?)

If I don’t know who’s good and who’s not I’m not going to protect a witch — I’d rather move on myself than skip a night and look guilty

Hunter is the healer, and loud.

The fact that he lives still is odd.

Splendidly odd.

The Librarian wrote:This doesn’t apply to me, but you really made it sound like you would kill people who ran into you with your protection.  You moved on yourself often as well, so my guess is people didn’t want to waste their move.  (Protectors affect all roles, right?)

What? I don’t kill anyone with my protection. I think you’re thinking of the carpenters traps?

The Aristocrat wrote:Hunter is the healer, and loud.

The fact that he lives still is odd.

Splendidly odd.

I appreciate this quote but my role title is “doctor” not healer (semantics)

Yeah I never got a killing protector claim…

I know that now, but your unwillingness to give your role description gave me that impression.

Because if the witches knew 1. The doctor was still alive 2. The doctor can stop the kill if the innocent was selected correctly or 3. The doctor can heal them the next night if it was made known out loud why would I want to give them that leverage so early

Which is why I made it known that 1. My role is not informative and 2. I listed where I went each night

I admit I've been thinking that things have been going too easy. And while I'd love to say claiming that you're moving every night saves you. It does not. At least not without someone else seeing it. Currently the only way you're evil though, is if an evil spirit did something wonky.