information aplenty

I am unsure what you want from me here. Since last night, several inexplicable things have happened, and that leads me to believe we need to re-examine our assumptions. I am but one person; I cannot solve the entire mystery single-handedly.

It may just be you have a very unfortunate role. One that is largely irrelevant and easy to fake, and one in which you do not leave your room.

Splendid.

It’s either that all are innocent on that list he gave the other night and the librarian is the witch OR that other list is the witch list.

Which means we’ll have to look and see if he DIDNT list anyone so far (as he wouldn’t list their fellow witches)

Were I a witch I would definitely list a fellow witch which has done killings already. They would be found eventually, and it would make me all the more believable.

I think we may need to know what the butcher’s role was.

And it would be helpful for you to come clean as well, Hunter.

All members of that list are cleared by the same person, essentially.
(Jailer clears farmer and Hunter, farmer clears butcher and drunk)

Respectfully I will decline. Telling what the role is would only empower the witches and I don't see how it helps confirm any of what I have said more than it already has been.

You all can choose to trust me or not.