I DONT KNOW WHO IS GONNA BE HERE NEXT OR IF ITS JUST CRONUS BUT LISTEN

First of all i appreciate you listening to my yelling because i did want yall to speak up. but in reality i KNOW there's three possible situations so here they are:

CASE ONE - the case that started it all --i.e. me talking shit--

INNOCENT:
Amadeus
Britannia
Cronus
Flavius
Godlevia
Horatia
Marilla
Octavius
Pontius
Primia
Romulius
Sabinia

BELIEVED TO BE GUILTY:
Derius
Justinia
Liviria
Titius
Valentinia

CASE TWO --i.e. the case due to who is the snoop--

INNOCENT:
Amadeus
Britannia
Cronus
Flavius
Godlevia
Horatia
Justinia
Liviria
Marilla
Octavius
Pontius
Primia
Romulius
Sabinia

BELIEVED TO BE GUILTY:
Amadeus
Derius
Flavius
Titius
Valentinia

CASE THREE --i.e. the case due to stories having to match and who is left--

INNOCENT:
Britannia
Cronus
Godlevia
Marilla
Octavius
Pontius
Romulius
Sabinia

BELIEVED TO BE GUILTY:
Derius
Justinia
Titius

THOSE TO BE QUESTIONED, BUT PAIRED ACCORDINGLY:
Amadeus AND Flavius
Liviria AND primia AND horatia AND titus -- titus in bold because he is just not innocent i'm sorry
---------------------------------------------------------------

I AM HIGHLY INCLINED TO GO WITH CASE ONE.
But what leaves me confused is that case three can also be just as likely.

Do with this as you please. but those on the innocent list of case three are definitely clear.