Who is remaining

Dumping some info here since numbers are low enough we should be able to have a pretty good idea of everyone’s role.

The Aristocrat; Watcher, confirmed by Reporter
The Carpenter; Trapper, unconfirmed
The Drunk; Snoop, confirmed by Monk and Farmer
The Gardener; Unknown, unconfirmed
The Hunter; Doctor, confirmed by dead Jailer
The Librarian; uhh… people innocentness diviner(?), not really possible to confirm
The Monk; Vigilante, not strictly confirmed but pretty obvious (the real vig would have stepped up by now, especially since they’ve been moving)
The Reporter; Banisher, confirmed by Monk, Librarian
The Youngling; Protector of sorts(?), unconfirmed

Putting the Librarian/Hunter business aside, nothing is confirmed for the Youngling, Carpenter, or Gardener. We have at least heard murmurings from the Youngling and Carpenter, but not the Gardener.

The Gardener has a small knife and a potted plant. Any ideas as to what their move could be?

Sounds like something stabby.

Splendidly stabby.

Innocents:
Aristocrat
Drunk
Hunter
Monk
Reporter

Witches:
Librarian

Ambiguous:
Carpenter
Youngling

My dear reporter your breaking news is music to my ears (I love the list)

Let me give you a special list. Of the following, at least 8 are not witches:
The Aristocrat
The Carpenter
The Drunk
The Hunter
The Librarian
The Monk
The Reporter
The Youngling

“Of the following, at least one is a liar”:
The Librarian

Nah, actually that was a truth. Well played

I mean.... I like the lists

Here’s a nugget of truth for you. On Night 4, I received the message “Somehow, you blocked the Shoemaker.”

Lie and a half because the innkeeper died and that wasn’t the monk’s doing

Tell your partner the carpenter to build your casket

That’s actually the truth. The spirit switched my move with the Educator, so I performed his move.

Admittedly, they could've used poison I guess the third night. But, I think we've got who we need to get.

And the spirit came from the dead board

So just because your move got switched with someone else’s means you’re not a witch? Lol ok

That would simply mean the educator did nothing that night because you’re not the active witch

That’s exactly what happened. Educator didn’t leave his room. Witch just isn’t the right term.

Are you new here? Because you’re literally a witch

Because otherwise the educator would have received your list

OH WAIT the lists are fake. I forgot

I’m glad you figured something out because now I’m confused.

your books and studies couldn’t help you here, huh?

To clear it up, you’re a witch. Simple

The only witchcraft came from the restless spirits of the dead. Maybe we should do something about that. All these roles and no gravekeeper.

You’re not even denying it anymore

@reporter — your breaking news is right here!!!

It’s… kind of old news at this point?

Shhhhhhhhh just make my loud statements louder