Gardener's Silence

Have they said, or done anything? Like at all?

No. All we have is from the Librarian night one saying either the Gardener or Carpenter is innocent.

Considering they're still in the grave they might be active in... "Other" ways.... Essentially I'm asking for a vote to if it's ok to go for them.

Looks like the Gardener has only posted on the rules and intro threads. Means they're either inactive or purposely silent.
I have a hunch they might be active but silent. No real evidence other than them remembering to post on the intro thread.

I think we add them to the lynch list. If they don't speak up, that's that.

I say start choking brother Monk.

I could also go for the nursemaid?

Saying it out loud gives the witches a chance to counter or change the active killer. Best to leave it a little ambiguous but I trust you.

Oh yeah. No this is more so if I should kill tonight. I'm not actually going to say who. I do love opinions though. Only God knows the answer... And maybe the Mayor.

The more two-death nights we have the more it clears you as the vigilante. Killing silent townsfolk in the absence of legitimate targets is acceptable.

Splendid.

The Farmer wrote:I say start choking brother Monk.

That’s what my father called it when my mother wasn’t in the mood.

Mr. Aristocrat, what does that mean? What wasn’t mommy in the mood for?

I'm gonna go now...

The Reporter wrote:Mr. Aristocrat, what does that mean? What wasn’t mommy in the mood for?

Says the innocent little boy with the Pedo-Palace in the woods.

If you’re interested I could bring you there too!

I’ve written and deleted five different comments.

Splendid.

He DOES have snacks there.