Discussing the Day 6 Lynch.

Other than someone’s gut feeling, why exactly are we lynching the Youngling? That seems awfully Vader.

Why do I seem to recall that earlier the Librarian gave info which we found to be false, or that he gave info on a night he was blocked, or some such falsehood. Perhaps he was later proven to be possibly telling the truth and I missed that.

Are we lynching the devil we don’t know instead of the devil we do?

Librarian, because of the three on that guilty list... Drunk, Hunter, and Butcher. All three were later proven to be innocent thanks to statements provided by the departed before they joined the afterlife.
Youngling... Well they're mostly just cagey and didn't really want to tell their role even though everyone else essentially has. Plus there seems to be a lot of protection type "innocents" which adds to the uncertainty.
That's what I recall at least.
I wish we could lynch the devil.

Librarian, “No Lynch” is not the vote to gain our confidence. It is you or the Youngling. Not neither.

The younglings items and list of moves just don’t add up so I wanted to go for a double of the youngling and the librarian

And (my opinion) if the librarian is going for no lynch as if we didn’t just list 3 options on who’s a potential witch it sounds like he’s trying not to vote for one of his own (which REALLY makes me think it’s youngling & librarian for sure. And then possibly nursemaid)

It’s not like he didn’t see the two people above him and the rest of the threads say youngling/nursemaid

I don't know how my items and moves don't line up- it's what I was given. There's really nothing on me besides me answering questions vaguely because I don't really trust any of you. Hunter's very quick to call people out....

The moves of the deceased point to the Hunter's innocence. I can't deny they call people out quickly though, haha.

Though arguably I'd rather lynch nursemaid considering she hasn't moved or spoken much in her defense at all.

Which moves of the deceased? So much as happened that I can't remember anymore. But I don't even know if I buy the poison thing, anyway. Do we even have any other evidence of the witches having poison other than his word/ role claim?

The Youngling wrote:I don't know how my items and moves don't line up- it's what I was given. There's really nothing on me besides me answering questions vaguely because I don't really trust any of you. Hunter's very quick to call people out....

I called you out slowly if we’re being honest cmon now

I still have not heard anything from the Nursemaid.

also where is the drunk???

I’m forcing a fourth vote to lynch. I find that splendid and fair.

We have about as much damning evidence on the Nursemaid as the Youngling.

At least the Youngling is willing to speak up a little, which is the reason for my vote.

I can just be quiet the next night/day cycle if you guys would like a day to figure this out if you truly want to go no lynch

For the record, this is why I'm opposed to double lynches. It's too easy for the bad guys to muster the votes and swing it.

I'm going to switch to Nursemaid and maybe salvage the lynch

Missed it by 2 mins

No lynch breaks ties it wouldn’t have made a difference

I'm just not sure why everyone decided to change it up all of a sudden. Seemed like we aligned earlier.
What's done is done I suppose.

I think Nursemaid is the most obvious choice next lynch. We should go one at a time and be satisfied.