Moves for Clarity

If those who have already shared where they went be willing to place it again in this thread? (I saw the reporter ask for my role and I’m more than willing to reveal it if I can read these one more time because I believe the educator OR the aristocrat could be a witch)

For me I did the following:
Night 1: myself
Night 2: aristocrat
Night 3: myself again
Night 4: farmer
Night 5: originally it was going to be the jailer because I thought either him or I would be the night target and then I changed it to myself around 9:54 (jailer I’m so sorry. You’d still be alive to my understanding if I didn’t switch )

Night 1: Woodcarver
Night 2: forgot to move
Night 3: forgot AGAIN to move I’m such a bad noodle
Night 4: Librarian
Night 5: Monk

Night 1: Shoemaker, nobody visited
Night 2: inactive
Night 3: Librarian, nobody visited
Night 4: Educator, visited by an Evil Spirit (Educator blocked)
Night 5: Monk, visited by The Reporter

Have at it, The Hunter.

Splendid.

I’m the doctor. I get to heal

I won’t state my items unless if the snoop is still out there (or if it IS the drunk)
But that makes me curious about the educator because I know for certain the “evil spirit” wasn’t a kill sickness.
If I picked the person who was targeted they would still be present (or if they “feel ill” from a poison I can heal the next night)

So that makes me think either 1 the librarian is lying or 2 the drunk is still the witch and the items he knows are other people who are also witches (which is why ideally I’d like to know what the butchers role was from the farmer because that’ll rule out whether or not he’s really an innocent or if they’re truly lying, KNEW they got the coroner, the note to the aristocrat is true which would THEN mean the farmer is a witch along with the rest of them)

To be fully transparent I believe the witches are the following:

Drunk, monk, shoemaker, butcher, farmer, and educator

But I promise I’m a doctor.

Not possible.

If the librarian isn’t on that list, at least one of the monk or the farmer is innocent.

And that would mean the killers killed off one of their own witches.

Replace the Educator with the Librarian and maybe.

The Evil Spirit was not a killing spirit, it was a blocking spirit. Likely a one-off ability.

I apologize I meant librarian!!!!! But yes

Hunter, does your healing prevent all manners of death? If so, you’re basically a protector.

The Aristocrat wrote:Replace the Educator with the Librarian and maybe.

The Evil Spirit was not a killing spirit, it was a blocking spirit.  Likely a one-off ability.

This makes the most sense!

Also, the farmer was verified to be innocent the same way you were: the jailer watched him go to the tailor on night 3

Gotchya gotchya so the farmer is good (sorry farmer. A lot happened tonight)

And the farmer said the drunk was correct when they named the butcher’s items days ago.

And the farmer claims the butcher was innocent, so no one would have access to his items except the snoop.

Apologies has the hunter had to rest to be the early bird to catch the worm — I *still* believe the drunk is the witch to be completely honest. Now that it’s morning I may be able to go back and reread to tie all of my logic together (a lot was going on last night)

I know the farmer said they decline to answer what the butcher was but that only makes me think the butcher and drunk are tied and possibly the farmer is “saying” the butcher was innocent just to add some space in time for him to figure out who else is lying himself?

The Aristocrat wrote:Hunter, does your healing prevent all manners of death?  If so, you’re basically a protector.

When I was assigned to be doctor I was told if they were a kill target then they get to survive and if a poison was used (delay kill) then I get the following night to cure it.

I don’t know if this correlates to “protector” or more of a “right place right time” if I pick the right person for the night.

I honestly could not tell you much more than that because I haven’t selected the right person on the same kill night yet

Really not sure why you're still suspicious after we've already established our innocence. If you trusted the Jailer was innocent then I'm vouched for.
Frankly we've been vouched for more than you though I do believe you're innocent.

Me revealing the Butcher's role doesn't do anything more to prove what I'm saying. If you don't believe me than I could just as easily be making up a role.

I do have to ask, did you pick up the vigilante role from the butcher? Because if that’s the case, could it have been that the Butcher was a murderer but for you that made you a vigilante because you are on the innocent team?

Trying to think of what else he can do with rotting meat and a knife and I’m not coming up with much.

You are correct in assuming I would become vigilante if I targeted a dead murderer.
But this is not the case with the Butcher.

Just gonna throw this out there, I'm not saying what the role is to deprive the witches of info they might use to decide on the best strategy for kill order. By guessing you're potentially helping the witches.

Vigilante was the one thing that may have ironed out some inconsistencies. I don’t need anything further, thanks much.