The Guilty List

Can you please verify that I'm not on the guilty list. It was compromised of... And if you don't believe me you can check...

The Butcher
The Hunter
The Drunk

I was on the possibly innocent list I think along with the youngling.

Oh! Oh crap! You are completely right.

I have it written out in front of me and everything.

🥲 thank you

So sorry. I actually do blame alcohol a little irl…

Also that dealing with the Hunter gives me a headache. Something is definitely fishy.
Drunk and Butcher cleared by Farmer

Hunter and Farmer cleared by Jailer

I will do what I can to undo that misunderstanding.

..... Did I murk an innocent man? If the jailer died and verified these people that would mean the list is fake. Oof I owe butcher an apology. I'm my defense they never tried saying anything in their defense!
That does make the librarian a witch though, by direct logic. But oh my... Don't use the Lord's name in vain Monk....
That would be arguably the best lie of any murder from the get go! A role that causes immediate suspicion! And he would of course known if he was blocked that one night because it wasn't just a block.... It was this!

So currently it's looking like librarian, shoemaker, nursemaid, and I'm still uncertain on the youngling. What about the carpenter? I also messed up my move it seems. Have to admit though the librarians role was an excellent lie

Yes, definitely an excellent lie!

Youngling, Carpenter, Gardener, Nursemaid, and Woodcarver have provided nothing in regards to their movements. They’re all on my list.

Honestly forgot woodcarver still existed . I'm not sure if I want to be presumptuous again. However, do you think I should attempt to smite one in particular? I know I'll be back by the night cycle.

Well if the woodcarver says his moves night 1 and/or 4 went through then he is definitely sus.

Why what happened night one with me? I feel like I missed something. Night 4 you got the librarian right?

Wait no I'm the night 4. I'm definitely forgetting the reason then

You were night 5! The Librarian was night 4

But I banished him night 1, so he couldn’t move

Are we really already on night 5??? Maybe I really do need to lay off the wine . He's definitely suspicious. Though if he digs, he'll be able to find out all of this anyways. So hopefully he slips.

Although something that can target living and dead is rare. Investigator would be the only thing I could think of.

Well that and the grave digger. Other than that I've got nothing

(yes I know the grave digger has already been claimed. At this point twice haha)