Town Roles

We are starting to get more information from the townspeople, so I thought we could use this to speculate about and list the roles of the remaining town members.

Aristocrat - Lookout maybe
Drunk - Could be blocker
Educator - Maybe Blocker (Drunk "couldn't have killed" on night one)
Farmer - Investigator, Medium, or perhaps a role where he learns the roles of the dead or even borrows them
Hunter - Protector, possibly the killing kind
Innkeeper
Jailer - Maybe Tracker (not a blocker as we previously thought)
Monk
Reporter - Info role (Tracker)
Woodcarver

This list is undoubtedly flawed, but even so there is very little room for the vigilante as they would have had no meaningful results up to this point. Innkeeper or Woodcarver perhaps? Some of the more potent roles could also be disguising themselves as info roles, but not vigilante.

Murderers
The Carpenter - Beater
The Gardener - Stabber (Night 2)
The Librarian - Burner
The Nursemaid - Poisoner (Night 3)
The Shoemaker - Strangler (Night 1)
The Youngling - Biter

Innocent
The Aristocrat - Watcher?
The Drunk - Snoop!
The Educator - Blocker?
The Farmer - Investigator/Medium?
The Hunter - Protector/Trapper?
The Innkeeper - ?
The Jailer - Follower! (Poisoned)
The Monk - ?
The Reporter - Tracker?
The Woodcarver - ?

Dead
The Tailor - ?
The Priest - ?
The Butcher - ?

I’ve got “?” Next to anyone we are unsure about and “!” Next to anyone that was confirmed.

Good list. I don’t think the Hunter is a trapper because traps typically stay on one person until dismantled. They moved on different people within the first two nights. I do think there is a chance they kill the attacker though.
We know the Monk’s items are wine and a rosary. That leads me to think their active item is the rosary, which lends itself to maybe a doctor or medium role. This is pure speculation of course.

Makes sense to me, I’m not sure which way it would be or maybe it’s both, but that certainly would be reasonable.